AI visibility tools, compared
7 tools that track how AI answers name brands, side by side in the same terms: the plan, how many engines answer each prompt, how sure each number is, and the API. RookAtlas wrote this guide and is one of the 7, so every fact about the others comes from their own pages, dated and linked.
RookAtlas opens soon and isn't on sale yet: its figures here are planned launch terms. The other tools are on sale today.
Who each one fits
Not a ranking: the tools on sale are listed alphabetically, each with a full comparison.
Selected facts, side by side
Each tool's entry plan as it documents it. “Not documented” means we didn't find it on the pages we read, not that the tool lacks it. Prices are in US dollars before tax.
| Tool | Availability | Plan compared | Engines per prompt | Uncertainty | API and MCP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RookAtlasPlanned at launch | AvailabilityOpens soonNot on sale yet; prices are planned launch terms. | Plan compared$45 a monthStarter, planned ($36 billed annually): 150 prompt runs a month, each on all eight engines, up to 1,200 answers. A Free plan too. | Engines per prompt8on every paid prompt run, Claude, Grok and Muse included; Free's monthly credits run on 3. | Uncertainty95% intervalson visibility and citation rates, with low-confidence and too-little-data labels. | API and MCPEvery planA REST API and an MCP server, Free included. |
| AthenaHQ Checked 12 November 2026 | AvailabilityOn saleA free Essential plan with 300 one-time credits on five engines.[1] | Plan compared$295 a monthStarter ($245 billed annually): 3,600 credits, one per answer, five for Claude, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI or Mistral.[1][2] | Engines per prompt11to pick from on Starter, Copilot included; each engine a prompt runs on spends its credits. Five on the free plan.[1][2] | UncertaintyNot documentedon the site and docs pages we read.[3] | API and MCPAdd-onAPI a paid add-on on Starter, included on Enterprise (its API docs say Enterprise only); an MCP server too.[1][4][5] |
| Otterly.AI Checked 12 November 2026 | AvailabilityOn sale7-day free trial, no card.[6] | Plan compared$29 a monthLite: 16 prompts a day on 4 of its 7 engines, about 2,000 answers a month.[7] | Engines per prompt4 of 7per workspace on Lite, Standard and Premium; all seven on Enterprise. Grok under evaluation.[7][8] | UncertaintyNot documentedon the product and help pages we read; its own study reports how far results move.[9] | API and MCPFrom StandardAPI, MCP server and Looker Studio connector from Standard, $189 a month.[10] |
| Peec AI Checked 12 November 2026 | AvailabilityOn saleFree trial, 7 days with no card by its own comparison page.[11] | Plan compared$95 a monthStarter ($80 billed annually): 50 prompts a day on 3 models, 4,500 answers a month.[12] | Engines per prompt3 of 8models, picked per plan; more from $30 a month each. Claude, Grok and Muse on Enterprise.[12] | UncertaintyNot documentedon the pricing, agency and docs pages we read.[13] | API and MCPAPI from ProMCP server on every paid plan; the API from Pro, $245 a month.[13][14] |
| Profound Checked 12 November 2026 | AvailabilityOn saleFree 7-day trial; Enterprise after a demo.[15][16] | Plan comparedCustomEnterprise, priced after a demo. The free 7-day trial runs 50 prompts daily on three engines.[15] | Engines per promptUp to 10on Enterprise, Claude and Muse Spark included; three on the trial. Grok and Copilot aren't on its pricing page.[15] | UncertaintyNot documentedin the product docs we read; metrics are averaged across models with equal weight.[17] | API and MCPEnterpriseThe REST API and the MCP server are on its Enterprise plan.[18][19] |
| Scrunch Checked 12 November 2026 | AvailabilityOn sale7-day trial of Core, card required; Enterprise through sales.[20][21] | Plan compared$250 a monthCore: 125 prompts on four engines, 5,000 answers a month, for one brand in one country.[22] | Engines per prompt4on Core: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews and Copilot; nine on Enterprise, Claude, Grok and Meta AI included.[22] | UncertaintySample sizes, signalsIts docs describe the sample behind each rate and statistically tested signals; we found no intervals on its rates.[23][24] | API and MCPAgency and upAPI keys on Agency and Enterprise; MCP on any plan by its docs, not on Core by its pricing table.[22][25][26] |
| Surfer Checked 12 November 2026 | AvailabilityOn sale7-day trial of Pro; billing details at checkout.[27] | Plan compared$95 a monthAI Search Analytics ($82 billed annually): 50 prompts tracked daily on its five engines; runs per prompt not stated.[28][29] | Engines per prompt5ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, AI Mode and AI Overviews; ChatGPT only on Standard. Its own notes say Claude isn't tracked.[30][31] | UncertaintyNot documentedon the pages we read; prompts run more than once and are checked for consistency.[30] | API and MCPMCP from $95MCP on AI Search Analytics, Pro and up; the API on Peace of Mind ($359) and Enterprise.[32][33] |
How we compare
- The tools are dedicated AI visibility trackers with public product and pricing pages, chosen by RookAtlas.
- Every fact about another tool comes from that tool's own public pages, numbered beside it and read on the date shown. We haven't tested them hands-on.
- A feature we didn't find reads “not documented on the pages we read”, never “no”.
- Each comparison says when the other tool may fit better, and works one set of prompts through both price lists.
- RookAtlas figures come from the same plan settings as our pricing page and are planned launch terms.
Product names are trademarks of their owners. RookAtlas is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by the tools compared here.
Sources
- 1AthenaHQ plans
- 2AthenaHQ credit calculator
- 3AthenaHQ docs: responses
- 4AthenaHQ docs: API rate limits
- 5AthenaHQ docs: MCP server
- 6Otterly.AI help: free trial
- 7Otterly.AI pricing
- 8Otterly.AI changelog, 10 November 2026
- 9Otterly.AI blog: AI search visibility stability
- 10Otterly.AI help: API
- 11Peec AI vs Ahrefs Brand Radar (Peec's page)
- 12Peec AI pricing
- 13Peec AI for agencies
- 14Peec AI docs: API
- 15Profound pricing
- 16Profound docs: credits
- 17Profound docs: how metrics are calculated
- 18Profound docs: REST API
- 19Profound docs: MCP server
- 20Scrunch FAQ: free trial
- 21Scrunch FAQ: what the free trial includes
- 22Scrunch pricing
- 23Scrunch help: metrics guide
- 24Scrunch API docs: signals
- 25Scrunch API docs: authentication
- 26Scrunch docs: MCP server
- 27Surfer help: how the trial works
- 28Surfer pricing
- 29Surfer help: AI Search Analytics
- 30Surfer AI Tracker
- 31Surfer: instructions for AI assistants
- 32Surfer help: Surfer MCP
- 33Surfer help: API introduction